Big Coal’s Bidding-New York Times Editorial

December 31, 2011-New York Times Editorial

This shovel removes 175 cubic yards of earth with each scoop. Notice the minuscule size of the man walking toward it. Photo © 1999 John Blair

It is a national disgrace that the strongest supporters of tougher mine safety concede that it will likely take another disaster before lawmakers will be willing to buck Big Coal and pass desperately needed safety legislation. “This is out of mind until another explosion takes place,” Representative George Miller, a California Democrat and sponsor of reform legislation, grimly predicted.

Republicans in both houses have led the way in stymieing worthy bills that address the many dangers and regulatory failings laid bare in the Upper Big Branch explosion that killed 29 miners in April 2010. Chief among them is the need for stronger fines for operators that violate safety rules or block safety monitoring — and a clear path for federal regulators to close the mines of serial offenders. Investigators need subpoena power. And whistle-blowers need protections against company intimidation.

These factors were cited in the West Virginia disaster in which federal investigatorsconcluded that the mine owner at the time, Massey Energy, was “systematic, intentional and aggressive” in putting miners’ lives at risk in a “workplace culture that valued productivity over safety.”

Two other inquiries offered a similar conclusion. Democrats, beginning with President Obama, need to do more to drive this issue before the public. Right now, the Miller bill and a similar measure from Senator John Rockefeller IV, a Democrat of West Virginia, are moribund in the face of industry and Republican gamesmanship.

Lawmakers worried about the next election have no excuse for ducking their responsibility to protect American lives. Voters, everywhere, should make them pay.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *